Fireside Cafe Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Fireside Cafe, a charming eatery nestled at 158 Toddy Dr, East Earl, PA. This delightful spot offers a cozy atmosphere perfect for breakfast and lunch, making it a go-to destination for families and friends alike. Customers rave about the chicken panini, which is served in an adorable box alongside chips and pickles—truly unforgettable! The café excels in drinks as well, with standout options like the blueberry iced tea and a variety of artisanal coffees that leave a lasting impression.
The inviting interior, complete with comfy seating and beautiful decor, extends to a lovely patio area, ideal for sunny days or cool, rainy afternoons. With ample space for both small gatherings and larger parties, Fireside Cafe strikes the perfect balance between charm and functionality. As you step inside, expect not only great food but also a warm, friendly vibe that makes you want to return again and again.
Kids Menu
Ham & Cheese
ham and cheese on one slice of sourdough with mayo
Mac & Cheese
Kids Grilled Cheese
cheddar and provolone on one slice of sourdough melted in the panini press
Pb & J
peanut butter and grape jelly on one slice of sourdough
Peach Matcha
A 16 oz. iced matcha, peach syrup, and whole milk.
Peach Sunset
A 16 oz. iced drink made with peach syrup, orange juice, cranberry juice and club soda.
Peaches And Cream Cold Brew
A 16 oz. iced drink made with cold brew, peach syrup, and sweet cream.
Peach Cobbler Latte
Double shot espresso, peach syrup, maple cinnamon syrup, ground cinnamon and milk.
Seasonal Drinks
Breakfast
Avocado Toast
Avocado mash, everything bagel seasoning, fresh dill, goat cheese crumbles, sourdough bread and topped with that special Caribbean Sauce.
Toasted Bagel W/Cream Cheese
Fireside Starter
1 cooked egg with your choice of protein cheese on your choice of breakfast bread
Breakfast Burrito
Avocado mash, bacon, cheddar cheese, 2 eggs, salsa, and sour cream on a warm tortilla.
Breakfast Sides
Greek Yogurt Parfait
Greek yogurt, blueberries, strawberries, granola, and amber honey drizzle
Broccoli Cheddar
Soup Of The Day
Smoothies
Tropical Harmony Smoothie
A delicious 16 oz. in-house smoothie made with banana, pineapple, mango, orange juice, and your choice of milk.
Berry Acai Smoothie
A delicious 16 oz. in-house smoothie made with fresh strawberries, acai, blueberries, raspberries, blackberries, your choice of milk, and sweetened with honey.
Green Smoothie
A delicious 16 oz. in-house smoothie made with pineapple, mango, ginger, banana, spinach, honey, and you choice of milk.
KCD Breakfast Sandwich
Toasted English muffin, sausage patty, American cheese and egg!
Kcd Breakfast Sandwich
Bottled Drinks (Kids)
Minute Maid Juice
12 oz. bottled Minute Maid juice.
Bottled Water
20 oz. Dasani bottled water.
Soft Drinks
20 oz. sodas.
Gold Peak Tea
16.9 oz. bottled Gold Peak tea.
Milk
16 oz. bottled Way-Har milk.
Cold Brew
House made cold brew. Low acidity & a smooth taste.
Latte
A wonderful blend of double-shot espresso steamed milk.
Americano
Espresso hot water.
Cortado 4 Oz.
Equal amounts of espresso steamed milk
Espresso Tonic
Double-shot espresso, simple syrup, and tonic water over ice.
Cold Brew Tonic
Cold brew with lemon juice tonic water. We add a touch of simple syrup for a touch of sweetness.
Mocha
A wonderful blend of double-shot espresso, steamed milk, and chocolate or white chocolate.
Hot Chocolate
House made chocolate syrup and steamed milk.
Drip Coffee Regular
Locally roasted coffee from Nostalgica.
Breve 4 Oz.
Espresso steamed half & half.
Espresso
A double shot of espresso.
Mojito Cold Brew
Cold brew with lime juice, mint and club soda.
Pour Over Coffee
Locally roasted coffee from Nostalgica brewed with the elegant Chemex. This process produces a more crisp & cleaner cup of coffee. Best enjoyed with no additives.
Espresso & OJ
Double shot espresso, simple syrup, and orange juice over ice.
Espresso Shaker 10 Oz.
Double shot of espresso shaken in a cocktail shaker with milk simple syrup.
Drip Coffee Decaf
Locally roasted decaf coffee from Nostalgica.
Coffee Drinks
Bottled Drinks
Soft Drinks
20 oz. sodas.
Gold Peak Tea
16.9 oz. bottled Gold Peak tea.
Minute Maid Juice
12 oz. bottled Minute Maid juice.
Bottled Water
20 oz. Dasani bottled water.
Milk
16 oz. bottled Way-Har milk.
Bear Claw Danish
A delicious bear claw with added sweet icing drizzle a fruit filling.
Chocolate Croissant
Buttery, flaky, and delectable croissant to start your day. Filled with dark Belgium chocolate.
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Delicious chocolate chip cookie.
Blueberry Muffin
Delicious blueberry muffin.
Snickerdoodle Cookie
Cinnamon Scone
Pastries
Lunch
Chicken Salad Sandwich
House made chicken salad (with added pecans cranberries), leaf lettuce, and mayonnaise, all on multigrain bread. All lunch entrees include a bag of chips pickle spear.
Tuscan Chicken Panini
Grilled chicken, spinach, tomato, pesto, and feta on sourdough. Served with chips a pickle spear.
Summer Harvest Salad
Grilled chicken, fresh strawberries & blueberries, feta, and pecans, on mixed greens with blueberry pomegranate vinaigrette
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Grilled sliced chicken breast, Stoltzfus Meat's bacon crumbles, shredded cheddar cheese, romaine lettuce, grape tomatoes, homestyle croutons, and ranch dressing.
Grilled Cheese Panini
Cheddar cheese, provolone cheese, oregano, all on sourdough bread
Chicken Bacon Ranch Panini
A delicious panini made with Stoltzfus Meat's bacon, grilled chicken, and cheddar cheese. All served on sourdough bread. Lunch items are served with chips a pickle.
BLT
Stoltzfus Meat's bacon, leaf lettuce, sliced tomato, garlic aioli all on toasted sourdough bread. All lunch entrees include a bag of chips pickle spear.
The Toddy Sandwich
Sliced deli ham, sliced provolone cheese, roasted red peppers, leaf lettuce, mayonnaise, red pepper pesto, red wine vinegar, all on sourdough bread. All lunch entrees include a bag of chips pickle spear.
Skip's Chicken Sandwich
***Only Available After 10:30AM Thursday-Saturdays*** A delicious hand-breaded, hand-tenderized & fried chicken sandwich! This sandwich is a meal in itself and includes house made slaw, pickles, Comeback sauce (sweet chili, ketchup, mayo, & mild spices) all on a brioche bun. This sandwich can also be found on Skip's Food Truck, a local food truck that serves the Lancaster County area. Comes with a pickle spear bag of chips.
Turkey Bacon Chipotle Panini
Sliced turkey breast, cheddar cheese, Stoltzfus Meats bacon, tomato, chipotle mayonnaise, and avocado smash, all on a sourdough bun. All lunch entrees include a bag of chips pickle spear.
Chicken Panini
Grilled chicken breast, provolone cheese, baby spinach, pesto, all on sourdough bread. All lunch entrees include a bag of chips pickle spear.
Chicken Caesar Wrap
A delicious house-made wrap made with chilled grilled chicken, parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing and leaf lettuce, all in a sun-dried tomato wrap. Served with chips a pickle spear.
Lunch Sides
Chicken Caesar Salad
Grilled sliced chicken breast, chopped romaine lettuce, shredded parmesan cheese, homestyle croutons, and Caesar dressing. All lunch entrees include a bag of chips pickle spear.
London Fog
Earl Grey tea, steamed milk vanilla syrup.
Matcha Latte
Matcha green tea mixed with cold milk vanilla syrup.
Dirty Chai Latte
A blend of chai spices and steamed milk vanilla syrup. A dirty chai has an added shot of espresso.
Chai Latte
Chai spices blended with steam milk vanilla syrup.
Brewed Tea
Two tea bags steeped in hot water.